• The Sideline
  • Posts
  • 🏈 What Howard Schultz Got Right (That Most Business Owners Miss)

🏈 What Howard Schultz Got Right (That Most Business Owners Miss)

The billion-dollar lesson hiding in your coffee cup

Author

Kinza Azmat
February 17, 2026

🏈 THE SIDELINE

Kinza here. This week I'm covering:

  1. Counterintuitive decisions that took Starbucks from 6 stores to 30,000

  2. Why Schultz's approach to employees created an unstoppable advantage

  3. The crisis moment that truly built business value

  4. And more...

The Decision Wall Street Hated

In 1988, Howard Schultz made a decision that Wall Street analysts called financial suicide. Starbucks was a small, growing coffee company trying to expand aggressively.

And Schultz decided to give comprehensive health insurance to part-time employees working just 20 hours per week.

The board thought he was crazy. Analysts predicted it would bankrupt the company. Competitors laughed at the inefficiency.

But Schultz did it anyway.

And it became one of the smartest competitive moves in retail history.

FROM THE FILM ROOM
🌎 Expand your thinking

  • Is roofing the next private equity play? (Link)

  • Don’t do this post-closing and screw your buyer over (Link)

  • Stripe’s CEO on advice for young people (Link)

  • Of course they’re putting ads in ChatGPT (Link)

    Most people use AI for personal productivity: things like writing emails, searching for information, and tutoring or advice. Meanwhile, higher value pursuits, like programming, make up a very small percentage of overall queries.

🛠️ Tool Stack of the Week:

The Real Competitive Moat

Most business owners think competitive advantage comes from better products, lower prices, or superior marketing. Schultz understood something deeper.

Your competitive advantage is the people who show up every day. Everything else can be copied.

By treating baristas like partners instead of replaceable labor, Starbucks created something competitors couldn't replicate. You can copy a menu or a store design. But you can't copy culture built on genuine care.

That decision led to Starbucks’ employee turnover at an industry low 65%…while the industry average was 150-300%. The cost savings from reduced hiring and training more than paid for the health insurance.

But the real advantage wasn't financial. It was cultural. Starbucks employees became brand ambassadors who genuinely cared about the customer experience.

Crisis That Proved Everything

In 2008, Starbucks was struggling. The company had expanded too fast and lost its soul. Quality had declined. Customer satisfaction was dropping.

Schultz returned as CEO and made another controversial decision. He closed every Starbucks store in America for an afternoon to retrain 135,000 employees on making espresso properly.

$6 million in lost revenue for a single afternoon.

Wall Street analysts called it theatrical and wasteful.

But Schultz understood that the company's value wasn't in the real estate or the supply chain. It was in the experience created by trained, engaged employees.

That single afternoon sent a message to employees: we care about doing this right more than we care about quarterly earnings. The cultural impact was worth millions more than the revenue lost.

What This Means for Your Business

Most business owners optimize for the wrong things. They chase revenue growth while ignoring the foundation that makes growth sustainable.

Schultz built Starbucks on a simple principle: take care of the people who take care of the customers. Everything else follows from that foundation.

It’s not business philosophy but rather hard-nosed competitive strategy.

When your employees genuinely care about the business, they solve problems you'll never see. They create customer experiences you can't mandate. They build reputation that marketing can't buy.

When your employees are just collecting paychecks, you get exactly what you pay for: the minimum effort required to not get fired.

Closing the Loop

Here's what most business owners miss: a business built on engaged employees is dramatically more sellable than one built on systems and processes alone.

Buyers can implement new systems. They can't instantly create culture and employee engagement.

When Schultz stepped away from day-to-day operations, Starbucks continued thriving because the culture he built was embedded in thousands of employees, not dependent on him personally.

That's the definition of a sellable business. One where the value isn't trapped in the founder's head or relationships.

The Hard Questions

  1. Would your best employees stay if you sold the business tomorrow? If not, you don't have culture. You have people loyal to you personally.

  2. Do your employees solve problems without being told? If not, you've trained them to wait for instructions instead of thinking like owners.

  3. Would your customers notice a difference if your entire team was replaced? If yes, your competitive advantage is more fragile than you think.

FINAL WHISTLE
Building Your Own Starbucks Moment

You don't need health insurance for part-time workers or multi-million dollar training programs.

But you do need to answer this question honestly:

Are you investing in your people like they're your competitive advantage, or treating them like replaceable costs?

Most business owners say people are their most important asset. Their budgets tell a different story.

Want to see where you stand as an owner?

Take the free quiz at 👉 Ownerquiz.com 

Cheering for you,
Kinza

How'd you like today's newsletter?

Login or Subscribe to participate in polls.

Reply

or to participate.